Planning tool · 2026 tax year

1031 exchange vs. sell vs. hold.

Three ways out of an appreciated property, compared side by side: pay the tax now, defer it into a replacement property, or let the step-up at death erase it. Built on the 2026 IRS parameters, including the 25% unrecaptured §1250 rate and the $15M estate exemption.

Your scenario

Property
$
$
$
%
$
Owner
$
If exchanging
$
$
$
$
If holding to heirs
yrs
%
$

Sell today

$830,080

cash in hand

Gain recognized$540,000
Tax on gain$109,920

A sale recognizes $540,000 of gain: $250,000 of unrecaptured §1250 gain taxed at up to 25%, plus $290,000 of capital gain.

§1031 exchange

$0

cash in hand

Gain recognized$0
Gain deferred$540,000
Tax on boot$0

No boot means no recognized gain. $540,000 carries into the replacement basis of $460,000 — deferred, not forgiven.

Hold to heirs

$2,191,123

heirs' value

Value at death$2,191,123
Income tax$0
Estate tax$0

At death, §1014 steps basis to $2,191,123, extinguishing $1,791,123 of gain for income tax. The estate is below the $15M exemption, so no estate tax applies.

Outcome by path

Dark bars are value kept; rust bars are tax. The hold path is measured at the assumed date of death, so its value reflects 20 years of appreciation — not a same-year comparison.

Exchange deadlines: replacement property must be identified within 45 days of closing and the exchange completed within 180 days (or the tax return due date, whichever is earlier). A qualified intermediary must hold the proceeds — taking cash before the exchange completes makes the entire gain taxable.

Assumptions and sources

  • · Tax year 2026 parameters: IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32.
  • · §1031: recognized gain is the lesser of realized gain or net boot (cash out plus net debt relief, netted against boot paid). Deferred gain carries into the replacement basis (IRS Pub 544; Form 8824).
  • · Unrecaptured §1250 gain (straight-line depreciation) is recognized first at a 25% maximum rate; remaining gain at 15%/20% (§1(h)(1)(E)).
  • · §1014: basis steps to date-of-death fair market value, extinguishing built-in gain for income tax.
  • · Estate tax: 40% above the $$15,000,000 2026 basic exclusion (Rev. Proc. 2025-32 §4.14). Portability can double the exemption for a surviving spouse — not modeled.
  • · NIIT: 3.8%, excluded for a materially participating owner's active business gain (§1411(c)(2)).
  • · Not modeled: state and local tax, §1231 lookback recapture, related-party or reverse exchanges, mortgage-qualification effects, and growth on sale or exchange proceeds.

This tool models one scenario for planning discussion. A CPA-signed EquityNav plan models your full picture — entity, state, portfolio and the years around the exit.